WiP - Avia Pasternak / Migrants and Collective Responsibility
WiP - Avia Pasternak / Migrants and Collective Responsibility
November 18, join the department in hearing about Work-in-Progress, this week from Avia Pasternak, on the topic of "Migrants and collective responsibility."
When democratic states commit serious wrongs, the costs of repair fall on their populations, through taxes and diminished public services. Recent accounts justify this burden by holding citizens liable for their state’s wrongs. But these accounts overlook non-citizen residents, who also share these costs. This paper asks whether they too are liable. I argue that, given that migrants lack electoral rights and, often, secured civil liberties, their relationship to their democratic state of residence is parallel to that of subjects of non-democratic regimes with their state. I then turn to attitude-based accounts of liability which are designed for non-democratic conditions. Applying these accounts to non-citizen residents, I argue that we have strong reasons to doubt that undocumented and low-skilled migrants are not liable for state policies, In contrast, high-skilled migrants often are. I conclude with implications for policy and for migrants’ duties of protest.